1.5-Inch New York Strip Steak, Well Done: Pull Temp & Cook Time
A 1.5 inch ny strip cooked well done needs about 30 min over 450 °F / 230 °C — roughly 15 minutes per side. Pull it at 151 °F / 66 °C; carryover takes it to 160 °F. Rest 10 minutes before slicing.
Step by step
- −40 minSalt and temperSalt generously and leave it out of the fridge. A 1.5 inch cut cooks far more evenly when it is not fridge-cold in the middle.
- 0:00On the grate at 450 °FGrill should be hot enough that you cannot hold a hand over it for more than 2 seconds.
- 15 minFlip onceDo not press it, do not poke it. One clean flip builds the best crust.
- 30 minPull at 151 °F / 66 °CProbe the centre from the side, not the top — you want the true core reading.
- + 10 minRest, then sliceIt climbs the last 9 °F to 160 °F off the heat. Slice against the grain.
Every method compared
Same 1.5 inch ny strip, same doneness — only the heat changes. Leaner than ribeye with a firm fat cap along one edge. Less marbling means less margin for error — the pull temp matters more here.
| Method | Pit temp | Cook time | Pull at | Rest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct Grilling | 450 °F / 230 °C | 30 min | 151 °F | 10 min |
| Reverse Sear | 250 °F / 120 °C | 1h 31m | 156 °F | 7 min |
| Sous Vide | 160 °F / 71 °C | 1h 46m | 160 °F | 0 min |
Pull temps differ per method on purpose: a 450 °F grill drives far more residual heat into the meat than a 225 °F pit, so the same final temperature needs a different pull point.
New York Strip Steak temperature chart
| Doneness | Final temp | Pull at (1.5 inch) | Looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rare | 125 °F / 52 °C | 116 °F | Cool red center, very soft. |
| Medium Rare | 130 °F / 55 °C | 121 °F | Warm red center — the sweet spot for most steaks. |
| Medium | 140 °F / 60 °C | 131 °F | Warm pink center, firmer bite. |
| Medium Well | 150 °F / 65 °C | 141 °F | Slight pink, noticeably drier. |
| Well Done | 160 °F / 71 °C | 151 °F | No pink. Use a fattier cut so it stays edible. |
Recommended Tools for Perfect Results
You cannot cook to temperature without measuring temperature. These are the two tools that change results the most.
Wireless Bluetooth Meat Thermometer
Leave-in probe with phone alerts. The single upgrade that ends dry brisket and grey steak.
on Amazon
Pink Butcher Paper (Unwaxed, 18")
Beats foil for the Texas Crutch: pushes through the stall while keeping the bark crisp.
on Amazon
Instant-Read Digital Thermometer
Two-second readings for spot checks and for probing brisket for tenderness.
on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and may change.
Other doneness levels at 1.5 inch
Other sizes
Download the printable temperature chart
Every temperature on this site on one page — beef, pork, poultry, seafood and low & slow, plus the carryover rule. Print it and tape it inside your grill lid.
One email with the chart, plus the occasional seasonal guide. Unsubscribe in one click, no spam. Prefer not to subscribe? Download it directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What temperature should a 1.5 inch ny strip be pulled at for well done?
Pull at 151 °F / 66 °C. Carryover cooking adds about 9 °F while it rests, landing on the 160 °F / 71 °C that defines well done.
How long does it take?
About 30 minutes using direct grilling at 450 °F. Times assume the meat starts fridge-cold and the lid stays closed.
Direct grilling or reverse sear at this thickness?
At 1.5 inch thick, reverse sear wins. Direct heat (30 min) burns the crust long before the centre is ready and leaves a thick grey band. Reverse sear takes 1h 31m but gives edge-to-edge well done.
How long should it rest?
10 minutes for this thickness. Tent loosely with foil — sealing it tight steams the crust you just built.